I guess I should’ve waited a few months before watching this remake of the 1950s classic. Maybe I would’ve forgotten how incredible the original was (unlikely), and then this may not have seemed so pedestrian (even less likely). Unfortunately, I didn’t wait, and I really disliked this remake.
First off, for those out there that say it isn’t fair to judge a remake against the original, and that I should just critique it based on its own merits, I disagree. If a studio is taking the easy route of remaking a film, then, by all means, I should be allowed to compare it to its source inspiration. That said, this remake is terrible compared to the original.
What I dislike most about the film is that the relationship between the boy and the alien is thrown out the window. What made the original so great was that special relationship the two had, and how it brought out the humanistic side of the alien. Here, where that human side is even more important, the filmmakers decided to toss in an obnoxious, annoying little boy, and have him hate the lifeless alien. It makes the end of the film even weaker, which is saying something.
This remake is a weak film that makes little sense. It takes virtually everything the original did and tries to “improve” upon it by adding more CGI, explosions, and more death, but it successfully rips out the heart that made the original so incredible.